AbstractView references

– Code smells are structures in code that present potential software maintainability issues. Manually constructing high-quality datasets to train ML models for code smell detection is challenging. Inconsistent annotations, small size, non-realistic smell-to-non-smell ratio, and poor smell coverage hinder the dataset quality. These issues arise mainly due to the time-consuming nature of manual annotation and annotators’ disagreements caused by ambiguous and vague smell definitions. To address challenges related to building high-quality datasets suitable for training ML models for smell detection, we designed a prescriptive procedure for manual code smell annotation. The proposed procedure represents an extension of our previous work, aiming to support the annotation of any smell defined by Fowler. We validated the procedure by employing three annotators to annotate smells following the proposed annotation procedure. The main contribution of this paper is a prescriptive annotation procedure that benefits the following stakeholders: annotators building high-quality smell datasets that can be used to train ML models, ML researchers building ML models for smell detection, and software engineers employing ML models to enhance the software maintainability. Secondary contributions are the code smell dataset containing Data Class, Feature Envy, and Refused Bequest, and DataSet Explorer tool which supports annotators during the annotation procedure. © 2024 Elsevier B.V.